The internet is not a democracy. When on a persons site, we do not have free speech. These truths admitted, when the users help build up a site, from the idea into a vibrant and useful community, it is sad to see the owner begin to get an ego. I speak in reference to a recent series of events on the WPG Photo forums. The owner of the forums seems to have forgotten that without the users, it would just be another useless collection of bits and bytes.
The Cause
A few months back, a rather vitriolic personality emerged on the forums. Goign by the name Hoopboy, the person was rude, insulting, and downright useless in several entries on the forum. Admitting that on these forums he could rest on his anonymity, Hoopboy continued to insult people on a regular basis, while providing no proof he had any talent at all.
A subject of one of his worse remarks asked the site owner to remove the comment, as it was a violation of the sites own policies and potentially harmful to the the subjects reputation, The person making the complaint was not asking for people's thoughts in the thread, only supplying his thoughts on another persons photograph, in a thread where the original poster was askign for comments.
The Effect
The site owner refused to take down the offending post, at which point the subject of the post stated that he may need to contact his lawyer. The owner, apparently, took this as a threat of legal action against the site and owner, and, in my opinion, over reacted, removing the post, but also the person who filled the complaint. That is right. He banned the user for complaining about a violation of the sites rules.
I then posted my thoughts on the matter, which earned me what I am told now is 'restricted posting' privileges. The site owner must approve all my posts, so he can screen what I say. I suppose criticism is a bad thing for those overly unsure of their own skills. My crime seems to be expressing my opinion, an opinion that the owner did not like, which reflected badly on his leadership and management of the site. I feel I told the truth, and his actions reflected negatively on him. Must just be me... and about a dozen other members of the site.
The Result
I suspect what I have planned next will incur far more wrath of the owner of that site than my recent actions. I also expect it will get me a full on ban at the WPG Photo site. However, I feel people need a place to speak their minds, not a place where they are expected to nod and smile at a person who is wrong, take abuse cause the owner doesn't want to enforce his own rules, all because the owner says so. There is a difference between having the right to express an opinion, and being rude and condescending. Stay tuned for more news in the days and weeks to come.
